👔 Classic Dad Joke
What did the Pilgrim say after a big meal?
That was Plym-mouth-watering!
Why This Joke Works
'Plymouth' — the Pilgrims' destination city — gets merged with 'mouth-watering,' the descriptor for an exceptionally good meal. 'Plym-mouth-watering' is a barely-legal portmanteau that works because 'mouth' is phonetically tucked inside 'Plymouth' if you lean into the right syllable.
🎤 How to Tell This Joke
Say 'Plym-mouth-watering!' with the satisfied sigh of someone who just had the best meal of 1621 — the Pilgrim is genuinely blown away, and their enthusiasm for the feast they helped invent is completely justified.
Perfect for:
- •Right after Thanksgiving dinner when everyone is leaning back and sighing in satisfied contentment
- •During a Thanksgiving history discussion about the original feast and what it might have tasted like
- •At a Thanksgiving hosted in Plymouth, Massachusetts, for maximum geographic and historical relevance
💡 Did You Know?
Turkey jokes dominate Thanksgiving humor, but the tradition of telling jokes at the table goes back to the original 1621 celebration (probably).
← Previous joke
Why did the turkey go to the gym before Thanksgiving?
Next joke →Why did the pumpkin pie win the baking contest?
More Jokes Like This
What did the Pilgrim say to the corn?
You're a-maize-ing!
Why did the Pilgrim refuse to tell a secret?
Because the corn had ears!
Why did the Pilgrim cross the road?
Because the chicken hadn't arrived on the Mayflower yet!
Why didn't the turkey eat dessert?
Because he was already stuffed!
What do you call a running turkey?
Fast food!
Want More Dad Jokes?
We've got 2,000+ dad jokes across 20 categories. Find your next favorite.